PERSPECTIVES → SECOND THOUGHTS Issue 990 · December 13, 2023

Rejoice in Trembling

This classic debate has only intensified today with the Hamas captive deal

Rejoice in Trembling

 

 

The hidden meaning of that mysterious, heavily laden phrase in Tehillim 2:11, gilu bir’adah, “rejoice in trembling,” has always eluded me.

Until now. With the hostage exchange, I am beginning to perceive a glimmer of understanding. We are joyous at the release of some hostages, while simultaneously trembling with worry about the price we paid, and fearful of the long-term consequences of this pact with the devil.

For Israel, where the value of human life is paramount, there was little choice, even though the pause was totally to Hamas’s advantage, destroying our momentum and enabling them to regroup and rearm. And everyone knows that the freeing of terrorist murderers from Israeli jails will come back to haunt us, as was true of previous exchanges.

Among the more painful aspects of all this is that not only has much of the world forgotten about the hideous slaughter of October 7, but in their eyes there is an equivalency in this exchange: “your prisoners for my prisoners.” World leaders and media, either maliciously or ignorantly, seem unaware that the trade involves “my innocent women and children who were brutally tortured and kidnapped against international law, for your convicted terrorists and murderers.”

Continue reading with Mishpacha.

Create a free account to keep reading.

Everything you need to stay close to Mishpacha.
← Previous installment A Different Commission of Inquiry Next installment → Letter to an American Jewish College Student