THE CURRENT → THE ROSE REPORT Issue 1056 · April 2, 2025

A Fly on the Wall Creates Buzz

The consequences of this security breach will be felt worldwide

A Fly on the Wall Creates Buzz

However, this alarming indiscretion at the highest security levels of the world’s greatest military superpower has subjected the Trump administration to international ridicule. In the long run, it raises concerns about whether the US security establishment can be trusted. Once again, it raises questions about whether President Trump appointed unqualified individuals to top defense positions during a period he described in his campaign as being on the verge of World War III.

Trump initially did himself a disservice by downplaying the situation. Ultimately, it is his decision if heads will roll. His hesitation to shake up his cabinet within his first 100 days is understandable, given the high turnover that plagued his first presidency. The House Intelligence Committee held emergency hearings on the incident — in which Jeffrey Goldberg, editor-in-chief of the Atlantic and a veteran reporter on national security affairs, was added to the Signal chat, where detailed operational information was posted during the US attacks. House and Senate Republicans, who have largely followed Trump’s lead, may have to distance themselves from him on this issue.

The entire affair raises numerous questions that lead to troubling conclusions, even with a personnel shakeup, provided that procedures remain unchanged.

Signal is a chat application with end-to-end encryption but is not resistant to hackers. Why are top defense and intelligence officials using this app to manage military campaigns instead of meeting in person, as Israeli officials do when they gather in the catacombs of the Kiryah in Tel Aviv? The distances in America are more significant, and it’s not as easy to convene all the relevant people in one place when they might be traveling across the country, but the military operation against the Houthis was not a sudden emergency. We can see from the chat that Vice President J.D. Vance initially suggested not hurrying into this.

Continue reading with Mishpacha.

Create a free account to keep reading.

Everything you need to stay close to Mishpacha.
← Previous installment Who's the Boss in Israel? Next installment → Ready, Willing, and Able