GREAT READS → NIGHTMARE COME TRUE Issue 981 · October 11, 2023

Taken Captive

Hamas’s kidnapping of large numbers of civilians has raised dilemmas that Israel has never faced before

Taken Captive
Israeli soldiers guard on a main road near the Israeli border with Lebanon, northern Israel, October 9, 2023. Photo by Ayal Margolin/Flash90 *** Local Caption *** צבא על גבול לבנון לבנונים גבול שטח כינוס הצפון קיבוץ גבול ארטילריה
The humbling of one of the world’s foremost hi-tech and military powers by a terror group was unprecedented, but Hamas’s kidnapping of large numbers of civilians has raised dilemmas that Israel has never faced before.
Can the IDF wage total war on a fiendish enemy and hope to preserve the captives’ lives at the same time?

 

For years, the scenario of a mass abduction of civilians by Gazan terrorists kept Israel’s military planners awake at night. Close behind a nuclear-armed Iran was the thought that Hamas would finally succeed in their long-held goal of snatching human bargaining chips.

Israel’s enemies have always known that its sensitivity to casualties was an Achilles heel, but the Gilad Shalit deal in 2011, in which 1,000 terrorists were exchanged for one Israeli soldier, taught Hamas the full extent of Israel’s vulnerability to kidnapping.

That thinking informed the long-running Hamas tunnel-building operation. The tunnels — dug deep into Israel — were intended to facilitate raids whose shock value was second to the big prize: hauling away soldiers and civilians as pawns in the great terror game.

On Shabbos this week those fears became a living, breathing nightmare, as Hamas and Islamic Jihad terrorists dragged away approximately 150 men, women, and children to captivity in Gaza. In scenes of brutality that demonstrated the deep-seated culture of violence in Palestinian society, terrified and defenseless women and children were paraded through Gaza’s streets as the spoils of a heroic war.

Continue reading with Mishpacha.

Create a free account to keep reading.

Everything you need to stay close to Mishpacha.
← Previous installment Istanbul Airport: Yom Kippur 5772 Next installment → City Under Siege