"I always enjoy reading Sarah Chana Radcliffe’s columns. This time though, I was really taken aback"
I read the article “Windfall,” about the woman who went from poor to very wealthy, and I felt compelled to respond.
I want to be clear that my response isn’t rooted in envy. I’m financially comfortable and extremely grateful for that. But coming from someone who grew up with limited resources, the tone of the article was especially disappointing — I would have expected a deeper sense of empathy and awareness, not self-absorption. Many readers may be facing genuine financial hardship without the privilege of newfound wealth.
Her complaints about being asked for money were particularly troubling. Does she not realize how difficult, and often humiliating, it is for people to ask for help? Framing those requests as burdens placed on her and her husband showed a painful lack of sensitivity. There was no recognition that being in a position to give is itself a blessing and responsibility.
Much of the piece read as a catalog of her current comforts: her closets are organized by a professional, she has full-time help, she eats nutritious preprepared meals and she can now buy designer clothing at whim. If I, someone who can also afford these things, found it unsettling, I can only imagine how this reads to someone struggling to put bread on the table.
Create a free account to keep reading.
