GREAT READS → AS THEY GROW Issue 991 · December 20, 2023

Ask Rabbi Greenwald: Issue 991

Why doesn't my daughter want to start shidduchim?

Ask Rabbi Greenwald: Issue 991
Why doesn’t my daughter want to start shidduchim?

MY daughter came back from seminary quite a few a months ago, and she’s not really interested in starting dating. She has always been very close with her friends, and she has one friend in particular who also announced that she’s not dating “for a while.” The two of them have lots of grand plans to travel, chill, and basically push off real life for a little bit. My daughter has a part-time office job, as does her friend, and they’re spending their considerable free time just having fun.
I’m happy she’s happy, and I don’t want to pressure her. Dating is stressful, and if she’s not feeling the stress, I’m glad. However, at what point do I stop smiling and nodding and tell my (legally adult) daughter that she needs to settle down and prepare for the next stage in life?

 

Y

our question has three aspects that need to be addressed: 1) your daughter, upon returning from seminary, is not interested in dating; 2) she has a friend whom you are not happy with, due to her values or lack thereof; and 3) your daughter seems interested only in having fun, but not in taking responsibility for her life.

In your story, all three seem intertwined. But it is important to treat these three issues as independent concerns.

 

WE

need to ask a few questions regarding your first concern: Should every girl at age 18 should feel pressured to get married? Is every girl that age ready to take on the responsibilities of marriage? How many girls actually get married in the first year after seminary? Lastly, did someone who only got married four years later lose out?

There is a lot of talk about the “shidduch crisis.” This seems to be a major reason for the pressure to get married as early as possible. I am not convinced that the solution lies in earlier marriages. A few years ago, in the pages of this respectable publication, ideas were set forward to “solve” the problem. A popular opinion held that boys should also begin dating at an earlier age, to close the gap.

Continue reading with Mishpacha.

Create a free account to keep reading.

Everything you need to stay close to Mishpacha.
← Previous installment Ask Rabbi Greenwald: Issue 987 Next installment → My Husband Is Denying Our Son's ADHD Symptoms